“Enthusiastic consent is really easy to determine, and I think if you don’t have that, then you’re not good to go,” Saxon Mullins, who was at the centre of a five-year legal battle against a man she accused of raping her, told the ABC’s Four Corners program in a story broadcast on Monday night. Sydney man Luke Lazarus was found not guilty of sexual assault, despite a jury and two judges finding that then 18-year-old Mullins had not consented to sex with him in an alleyway behind his father’s Kings Cross nightclub in 2013.
He was granted a retrial with a judge alone, who agreed with Lazarus’s version of events and found that Lazarus had no reasonable basis for believing Mullins had not consented, but that Mullins, in her own mind, had not consented. The judge had to decide whether Lazarus knew Mullins wasn’t consenting and on that point, she found the prosecution hadn’t proven its case.
“All you need to say is, ‘Do you want to be here?’ And very clearly, ‘Do you want to have sex with me?’” the now 23-year-old Mullins said. “And if it’s not an enthusiastic ‘yes’, then it’s not enough. If it’s not an enthusiastic ‘yes’, it’s a ‘no’. That’s it. And then, you’re committing a crime.”
“[Saxon Mullins has] been humiliated in an alleyway at the age of 18, she’s had to tell her traumatic story in court, she’s had to face two trials, two appeals, and still, no final outcome,” Speakman said at a press conference in Sydney on Tuesday morning.
“From her viewpoint, the whole process has been, I imagine, just a huge disappointment. “This young woman’s bravery in coming forward and sharing her story is commendable. The delay and uncertainty in this matter was unacceptable.”
“Anyone who saw Four Corners last night cannot argue against the need for sexual consent laws in NSW to be strengthened,” Faruqi said. “Consent cannot be inferred through a person’s silence or assumed if a victim does not physically resist. Consent must be redefined as active, positive, and voluntary, and our laws must change to reflect this.”